Main Content


Michael McCoy
MeetMichael McCoy

When you live and breathe your work like Michael McCoy does, success ultimately follows. A constant Top Producer in Cutler’s German Village office and frequent Top Producer for the entire company, Michael brings over 15 years of successful real estate experience to Cutler Real Estate. His previous experience includes being an associate of one of “The Wall Street Journal/ REAL Trend’s Top 250 Teams in the United States”. In addition to his work in Columbus, Michael worked for one of the most highly respected residential brokerage firms in New York City, Halstead Property.

Michael takes pride in his profession, providing clients with the highest level of privacy and discretion, great trust and loyalty, plus a vast knowledge of today’s unique marketplace. A talented and hard-working individual, Michael has earned not only outstanding results, but has secured a very positive reputation within the real estate industry. He truly recognizes that buying and selling a home are personal and emotional as well as financial transitions in the lives of his clients. He helps ease the process by injecting his own seasoned personal and professional judgment to aid in the important decision-making process.

As a seller’s broker, Michael provides a marketing service that is both unique and effective, combining refined selling skills with marketing methods that fully embrace the digital age, enhancing the exposure of the property, and thereby maximizing price. His negotiating skills have produced the results that his clients expect. His clientele ranges from firsttime sellers to seasoned multiple-dwelling owners of million-dollar homes.

As a buyer’s broker, Michael’s keen eye, listening skills, and attention to detail have kept his customers unquestionably loyal. With eternal patience, he identifies his customers’ specific needs to match them to the best possible property, often identifying opportunities that others were unable to see.

Michael grew up in Upper Arlington, Ohio. He holds a BA from The Ohio State University with a focus on Marketing and Sociology. An avid traveler, Michael prefers to be outside, whether it’s a run around German Village, brunch at an outdoor café, or admiring the architecture of the historical neighborhoods of Columbus and abroad. Michael is a member of the German Village Society, The Athletic Club of Columbus, Real Estate Board of New York, Downtown Residents’ Association of Columbus, among other professional and philanthropic charities and organizations. Michael is licensed in both Ohio and New York.


Full Service at Your Service

I am passionate about delivering exceptional consumer experiences. By offering a complete suite of real estate services, I ensure that I meet my consumers’ every need. From sales and rentals, to mortgage, designers, contractors, and title insurance, I have experts in every field to guide you skillfully from beginning to the end of your real estate journey.

With nearly a decade of experience in residential real estate, including invaluable New York City experience, I have marketing and negotiating skills that produce the highest rate of success in arranging transactions for clients. Further, I share a commitment to discretion that is absolute. When you hire me, you get direct access to me. You’re not hiring my assistant or a buyer’s agent. What you will receive is a team of professionals working behind the scenes. This starts with our full-service in-house marketing team dedicated to the delivery of solutions tailored to my exclusive listings.

All creative ideas are brought to life in collaboration with my talented art staff creating a superb look and finish to all of my work. This marketing department specializes in all mediums including traditional display advertising and web advertising to target and place our properties to the best niche audience and demographic. Creative display advertising, web ads, property postcards, brochures and window displays are just a sampling of what is produced to gain my listings the best exposure. My team creates designs that accentuate the unique qualities of my exclusive listings.

What does this mean to you? These combined efforts and experience translate to real returns and a better bottom line for my clients. You can feel comfortable knowing you have a true professional in your corner. I appreciate your confidence and consideration.


Michael David McCoy

Work With Me

    Skip to content